To pay or not to pay for reviews…

Reviews – all authors need them – even the bad ones. But it’s hard to know where to look for quality reviewers or bloggers when an author puts out a new release. I know I’ve talked about reviewing before, and I am NOT shy about stating my negative feelings on reviews that are mini-summaries or book reports, laying out the entire plot in one big public dissection. But this post isn’t about that. It’s about those reviewers or bloggers who expect to get paid for reading a book and then posting about it on their blog.

Now, if reviewing or blogging is your business and you actually pay taxes on the money you make, then I suppose making money doing it is totally fine. But what I’ve discovered since self-publishing my first book, is that in the Indie world, the regular Joe or Jane has gotten a bit big-headed about getting paid to do something they do anyway – read and tell others what they thought. The reviewing world is exploding – with everyone from Kirkus Book Reviews to your neighbor reading all the books they can get their hands on and then posting on a blog or website what their thoughts and experiences were. Again, let me reiterate that all books really do need reviews. But the best of them come in organically, when a reader bought the book and has had such a passionate experience (be it positive or negative) that they simply MUST shout their opinion to the world. These are the reviews that are my favorite – because they are honest.

I’ve always had a problem with paying for a review. For one, if you are giving your book to someone for free, which you spent months or years writing, editing, formatting and marketing, and they say they will review it honestly for free – it’s sort of an equal and balanced arrangement. But if you give your book to someone with the sole intent of them reviewing it, you run the risk of their review being biased toward the author. I am still very careful with this. I only gift books to interested people who I trust will review in a timely manner and in an honest and spoiler-free way. If one of those people then came to me and said, ‘Oh, I charge for this now. If you want me to read and review the book or share it on my blog, it will cost you…’ then I’d never send them another book. Ever. Never, ever. Why? Because, those aren’t the kind of business relationships I strive to build. And honestly I can’t afford to pay everyone to read my book and review. I have paid for mini tours. That’s a totally different thing, IMO.

Anyway, think about this for a second: It costs money to self-publish. There’s outsourcing that can include anything from co-authors, editors, graphic designers for covers, stock images or artists for covers, formatting, and there are supplies needed like printer ink, computer maintenance (I had to buy a new laptop last year, for example) binders, ink, etc… Also, there are the costs for marketing, like blog tours, announcements, business cards, book tours and swag. Some Indies even have agents who snag a percentage of sales, or assistants to help them manage everything. Self-publishing can make you more money (IMO) in the long run of course, but you DO put out a lot as well. So, to have a reader say that they will be charging to read and review a book is kind of frustrating and, well, to be honest – lame. I won’t even send a book to Kirkus (an established and respect place for authors to go for reviews) because I worry what the Indie world would think if I ‘paid’ for reviews. It’s a scary line to cross. Paying for feedback might seem to some that the author pays for favorable reviews. I know it’s happened. And I don’t want to be lumped in that group…ever.

Now, it seems the blogging community is making a killing charging authors to feature their book on their blog, review it or interview them. Meh.

You might be wondering how this came about today…well, I saw a post on Facebook that I couldn’t ignore because it ticked me off so badly that I actually felt my blood pressure rise. I’ll share the image here with you, and let you form your own opinions on the original poster and their ‘stance’ on this subject. I don’t know the person, I’m only reacting to the post. It was shared from a page that does not support bullies in the writing community – something I appreciate more than words can say. If you want to know more about them, you can find them on Facebook at Authors & Bloggers Against Bullying. Anyway, here is the post that spawned this blog today:

FB Image

The original poster seemed to be miffed that some authors didn’t want to pursue using their ‘services’ when it came to mentioning their book on their blog (I’m guessing by an author interview, or book review). I’ve been tagged on Twitter countless times by bloggers who reviewed one of my books unknowingly – for absolutely free. I doubt they did this with the intention of then charging me for their time. And each time that happens, I swear my heart expands another centimeter because it means someone out there read my work and enjoyed it enough to tell their friends. The funny thing is, I get why some bloggers would charge for promos and I have no problem with that. It takes time to set up posts and make everything look great and spread the word to their followers, but the people following those blogs are there to learn and be entertained about the subjects at hand. I wonder how many would stick around if they knew that the bloggers only featured books or authors on their site that paid for the service? Again, it’s a line I don’t like to cross. I’m more than happy to pay someone to organize a book tour…but to pay them to read the book and feature it on their book blog…yeah, I don’t have a budget for that. Often I feature authors and their new releases on my own blog and I would never dream of charging them for that. It’s called networking, and I’m happy to do it.

In conclusion, as an author, I know I need (and love) my readers, reviewers and those awesome bloggers out there that take the time to read my work and share it with their friends and followers. I appreciate every single review and blog post – I really do. I work hard to get my work out to the masses and love to see it enjoyed. However, it’s the few out there simply looking to make a buck off the reading and writing community I don’t have the time of day for. They can move on to the next author, I’m totally fine with that.

To quote one of my favorite songs from The Pretenders, “It’s a thin line, between love and hate…” and I suppose, the reviewing world fits perfectly with that sentiment. Wow, is that ever true. LOL

But y’all know I love you. I can’t live without you. Seriously. *wink, wink*

8 thoughts on “To pay or not to pay for reviews…

  1. Amy C says:

    I can’t imagine being so arrogant as to start charging for my reviews. I think it is a privilege to get an advanced copy of a book to read. If there was money involved, I would feel obligated to give a better rating than I might have without the ‘incentive’. As it is, I feel bad giving a three or four star review to a request. On the rare occasion that I get a book that I feel a requested review requires a one or two star rating, I just refuse to leave a review at all. Some authors do not respond well to anything less than 5 stars. I won’t deal with the backlash from a very poor review. That is my payment to myself; to enjoy the process and save myself from abuse and headaches when I can. No money needed. 🙂


  2. Cat Alley says:

    As an avid reader, blogger, and book review I would never think to ask to get paid. The say I see it is exactly as you put it. You GAVE me a book for free, so I am giving you a review for free in return. We each get something we really want. I get a book and you get a review. And about the way someone reviews. If I am reading up on a book, I always check the reviews. If someone goes into details about the book I will always skip it as I don’t want to basically read the book before hand. That spoils everything. As a reviewer I try to do mine vague enough to not give detail about the story, but with enough meat to attract people. That is the way it should be done. Sometimes that is hard, but it should be tried.


  3. hodgescheryl says:

    To CHARGE for a review is just plain VANITY at it’s best. I don’t have my blog so my reviews go on ,Goodreads, and Facebook and I feel PRIVILEGE to do so.! I have a handful of favorite indie authors, YOU included Trish and I’m so GRATEFUL when I receive an Arc copy to read just because or in exchange for a review. In fact I usually still purchase the book even after I read the Arc copy because I know that’s a big loss of MONEY and TIME for the author. And being an indie author is a major cost because they’re trying to get they’re work out there. Bottom line is I feel PRIVILEGE to give my review after I’ve read any book free or not free. And what’s more rewarding is when my FREE reviews encourage the people reading them to purchase the book I’ve just reviewed. For those of you that feel your reviews are worth paying for, get a real job because anyone can get paid to LIE!! ((;


  4. Charlotte Howard says:

    I refuse to pay for reviews – I would rather have a real negative review than a fake positive. I once had an email from a “reviewer” offering to review my book for around $250, oh and both a print and e-book. For $500 they would guarantee a 5-star review on Amazon and Goodreads! I think I’ll stick to my one or two, here and there, reviews from people who comment on whether they liked the book or not rather than a full book report that includes spoilers.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s